Despite studying neuroscience and philosophy at Boston College, I chose wealth management and now serve at Feighan & Associates, managing over $1.5 billion through Ameriprise. This unexpected journey taught me something crucial: professional financial guidance extends far beyond investment decisions. Russell Investments' 2025 study quantifies what I see daily – advisors add 4.87% annual value to portfolios, nearly five times the typical fee.
I never expected Ameriprise. Having attended Carroll School focused on neuroscience, philosophy, and psychoanalysis, I craved the intensity of private equity and The Big Short drama. Private wealth seemed sleepy, traditional. Couldn't investors handle this themselves?
Now, as a licensed private wealth manager with Accredited Behavioral Finance Professional certification, I understand the profound value advisors bring. The data speaks volumes.
The Quantitative Case: Russell's 4.87% Annual Value
Russell Investments' 2025 study organizes advisor value into four components:
A: Asset Allocation (0.30%) Self-directed investors often default to familiar classes, with AAII surveys showing many keep 20% in cash – a costly comfort zone. Advisor-directed portfolios with broader diversification (small-cap, international, emerging markets, real assets, only 5% cash) deliver risk-adjusted returns through proper rebalancing.
B: Behavioral Coaching (2.47%) The biggest value-add: preventing emotional decisions. During March 2020's COVID panic, investors withdrew $330 billion, missing a 63% recovery. Morningstar confirms: while the S&P 500 delivered 13.88% (2010-2024), average investors achieved only 11.41%. Annual emotional cost: 2.47%.
C: Customized Family Wealth Planning (1.13%) Modern advisors provide comprehensive services beyond portfolios: retirement/succession planning, legacy/charitable strategies, and personalized ESG or faith-based approaches. This tailored approach adds 1.13% over robo-advisors.
T: Tax-Smart Planning (0.97%) Through asset location strategies, municipal bonds, and capital gains harvesting, advisors reduce tax drag from 2.1% to 0.1% annually, creating 0.97%advantage per Morningstar.
Total: 4.87%. After 1% fees, clients net 3.87% annually. Compounded over decades, this means hundreds of thousands extra.
The Qualitative Dimensions
Emotional Discipline: My behavioral finance training reveals how fear drives irrational decisions. Many lack education to act in their financial best interest, particularly with irreversible choices like IRA-to-Roth conversions.
Managing Complexity: Financial decisions impact marriage, career, parenting, legacy. Advisors connect dots across life stages, reducing anxiety.
Reduced Stress: Lives are busy. Brenda*, Johnny, Alberto* are stressors enough. Worry about Brenda's passive-aggressive Instagram DM congratulating you on "still looking good" despite weight gain. Offload finance to professionals.
Time/Accountability: Managing investments requires specialized knowledge. Advisors provide framework for progress – easy to procrastinate without structure.
Human Element: Asked whether AI threatens my profession? No. FINRA/SEC requirements ensure human oversight. Technology can't ask "How's your mother's illness?" Families entrust me with livelihoods. This demands technical expertise and human understanding.
The Real Cost of Self-Direction
Since starting, I've discovered the most common question concerns fees. Many focus on the 1% charge, overlooking hidden self-direction costs:
- Missed returns from excessive cash
- Emotional missteps during volatility
- Inefficient tax planning
- Misaligned portfolios
I pose this question: When sick, do you self-diagnose? Visit the doctor? Pay them? Then bargain after getting better?
We seek medical professionals despite cost because stakes are high and knowledge specialized. Financial health deserves the same respect. The question isn't whether you can afford an advisor; it's whether you can afford navigating complex markets without one.
Many try bargaining on fees. This frustrates me most. Brenda, sit down. I'm doing you a favor addressing your issues, girly pop!
Looking Forward
In our uncertain world, having a trusted advisor isn't luxury – it's necessity. The data is clear: professional guidance delivers measurable value exceeding cost. But beyond numbers lies confidence knowing your financial future is in capable hands, aligned with values, structured for whatever challenges ahead.
Idea: Like insurance covering doctor visits, could someone create a co-pay company for Americans to access financial advisors? Interesting.
*Brenda, Johnny, Alberto are fictional, not real clients or people.
Reference
Russell Investments, 2025 Value of an Advisor Study
Together, we can work to keep you on-track toward your financial goals.
Request a consultation to learn more.
Read more articles by Feighan & Associates